I’ve been there, I know the way: the NZ passenger rail book is happening!

I am very pleased to say that Otago University Press are going to publish Can’t Get There from Here: New Zealand’s Shrinking Passenger Rail Network, 1920–2020, my collaboration with mapmaker Sam van der Weerden. The book will come out in 2021; it is tentatively scheduled for September.

It will be lavishly illustrated. Sam’s maps look incredible, as you can see from the sample below. There will also be at least sixty photos, some never before published (even on social media! quite a feat if you know me). I’ve included a handful of low-res samples in this entry.

https://caffeinatedmaps.files.wordpress.com/2020/06/forblogcgtfh-01.png?w=1024
Sam is good. Sam is really good. Plus, he’s had to put up with me changing my mind or finding new information really late in the game. What a legend.

The text is, I believe, one of the most thoroughly researched narratives on New Zealand railway history to date. It draws heavily on Archives New Zealand’s vast collection of New Zealand Railways (NZR) files, as well as material held at repositories such as the Hocken Library and Southland District Council Archives. It also makes use of newspapers—not just those on Papers Past; I’ve done my time with the microfilm machines—annual reports to parliament, consultants’ reports, autobiographies, and more.

The inspiration for Can’t Get There from Here came from an unlikely source: a late-night Twitter discussion about former passenger rail services in New Zealand. I made a little timeline of when each service started or finished for the past century, and the next morning it seemed like it would be worth my while to turn it into an article for a journal of historical geography. A few thousand words later and I realised I had a book on my hands. I also realised that I needed to work with a mapmaker or else the book would be inscrutable to anyone without a thorough knowledge of New Zealand geography. The very talented musician Anthonie Tonnon was another participant in that discussion, who introduced me to Sam and his mapmaking talents.

I love this photograph: AB 609 with a passenger train for Little River passes a maintenance worker on a jigger in the Christchurch suburb of Sockburn on 28 March 1950.
Credit: J.F. Le Cren, Archives New Zealand (ANZ) AAVK 6390 B31.

So, what’s the book all about? If you’ve tried to travel around New Zealand in the last couple of decades, you’ve probably realised that you won’t get far without a car. Rail patronage is booming in Auckland at the moment and Wellington has a longstanding electrified commuter network, but beyond those two cities you’re unlikely to find a passenger train, let alone one going your way. If you do, it’s probably a tourist service—KiwiRail brands these as the Great Journeys of New Zealand, slow and expensive trains for leisure travel. Good luck finding the Everyday Rapid Journeys of New Zealand, efficient and affordable trains for people such as business travellers, families, or local shoppers.

It was not always like this! I’m a millennial from the Kāpiti Coast who grew up poring over railway books, and I suspect most of my peers and those younger than me haven’t a clue that passenger trains used to criss-cross both islands. After all, why would they know this? If you were fifteen in 2002, as I was, long-distance rail travel in New Zealand was basically dead. But New Zealand once had good passenger rail, and it could have it again. Nothing was inevitable about its decline, and the outcomes of economic and social change were not predetermined or inexorable. The choices of people shaped the network, politicians and stationmasters alike.

Press (Christchurch), 13 April 1928, 15.

In 1920, you could travel to pretty much any reasonably sized town by train, and many tiny villages too. If you saw a railway line, a passenger train would almost certainly come along sooner or later. Things changed a little by 1967, but at the start of the year trains could still take you to most major destinations and a handful of rather obscure ones. Things changed a lot by 1982, but even at the start of that year you could catch a suburban train in Dunedin or trundle along the rails through northern Taranaki. Now, if you come upon a railway outside Auckland or Wellington, it probably only carries freight.

Why did the network contract? I thought a good way to understand this would be to look at how it has evolved over the past century. I decided to investigate not just when but also why each service started or finished.

Can’t Get There from Here shows that the contraction of New Zealand’s passenger rail network was partly the result of technological change and mainly the outcome of deliberate decisions and government policies. The rise of private motor transport brought an end to the expansion of rural passenger services in the 1920s. As early as 1924, many officials within NZR believed that improved services competitive with road were unaffordable—often over-estimating the cost of upgrades. The effects of the Great Depression compounded this decline and NZR hoped to save money by cancelling services to lightly populated areas. It also began using buses rather than trains to carry some passengers. This became increasingly common from the mid-1930s: bureaucrats perceived buses as more modern and efficient, even as travellers questioned their motives—were buses better, or just a way to charge passengers more for the same journey?

The Ōtira Tunnel through the Southern Alps was New Zealand’s first electrified railway; it was much too long for steam engines. Pictured are two of the five EO class locomotives with a passenger train not long after the tunnel was finished in 1923.
Credit: A.P. Godber, Alexander Turnbull Library (ATL) APG-0324-1/2-G.

World War II spurred completion of major interprovincial railways as petrol and tyre shortages stimulated record train patronage. Trains were essential to domestic mobility at wartime, but the arrival of peace brought serious problems—the railways were rundown and coal shortages reduced train frequency and reliability. Passengers shifted modes. Bureaucrats continued to prefer buses; the allure of American-style freeways attracted politicians. NZR cut services in the belief this met demand where it was, sometimes at the insistence of Treasury; in reality, this further dissuaded potential travellers. It might go without saying that I am a little more critical of senior NZR management and their decision-making than some previous authors have been—a few were former NZR men themselves.

By the 1970s, passenger rail had gone from an everyday form of transport to one that was increasingly unfashionable and unprofitable. Politicians from both Labour and National dithered and then rejected opportunities to revitalise services; some railway administrators even cancelled some routes in underhanded ways to avoid public criticism. Ridership statistics were routinely taken as the full extent of the market for train travel, with no attempts made to grow patronage. There were meaningful attempts to improve and expand rail between 1987 and 1991, but this was a false dawn. Service cancellations in October 2001 and February 2002 left New Zealand with a passenger rail network smaller than at any time since 1877.

Palmerston North station was a loud and smoky presence in the centre of town back in 1937. The current station on the city’s fringe in Milton opened to passengers in 1963.
Credit: Manawatū Heritage / Palmerston North City Library 2007N_Rm30_RAI_0678

The final chapter looks to the future. I could not conclude the book without indicating developments that are already on the cards—Te Huia between Hamilton and Auckland will start running in early 2021, and Auckland’s City Rail Link is planned to open in 2024. I also felt that the preceding chapters suggested further possibilities. Sam and I have prepared maps and text that propose options for our cities and regions. These are historically-informed conversation starters that show how we can improve mobility for all New Zealanders. Fundamentally, we believe that rail transport is important for our communities, essential to improving mobility, and a valuable technology to address the effects of climate change.

And, yes, if you are an REM fan, you’ve probably guessed the source of the title:

Hands down, Calechee bound
Landlocked, kiss the ground
Dirt of seven continents going 'round and 'round
Go on ahead, Mr Citywide, hypnotised, suit-and-tied
Gentlemen, testify

(I've been there, I know the way)
Can't get there from here
(I've been there, I know the way)
Can't get there from here

Last, here are a few images that I think are going to miss the cut. They are still low-res, just in case they do sneak in, but please enjoy.

The Gisborne Express on its way out of Wellington with ED 102 at the helm in 1949. No motorway, eh.
Credit: J.F. Le Cren, ANZ AAVK 6390 B1446.
I was going to illustrate the isolation of northern Taranaki with this photo I took of the unsealed portion of State Highway 43 in the Tāngarākau Gorge in October 2018. This is the last unsealed section of the state highway network. But it does not feature a train and I can probably do better.
Whanganui sits on a branch line; the main line between Marton and New Plymouth passes through its northern suburb Aramoho. This aerial photo shows the junction in Aramoho on 6 April 1955; a with-car goods train is at the platform. Today, the station no longer exists and the yard has been lifted.
Credit: Whites Aviation, ATL WA-37584-F
A photo I took of one of Wellington’s Matangi electric multiple units arriving at Pukerua Bay on 8 December 2018.
It was 10 December 2011 and I wanted to get a photo of a goods train from Napier to Gisborne. I was, unfortunately, too late, so I took a bunch of photos of Eskdale station instead. I hoped I might have an excuse to include one in the book—but I don’t think I do.
The book is about routine passenger services, so this does not really fit. It is a photo I took at Masterton station on 20 November 2011. In the siding are Wairarapa Connection carriages, as you might expect. But DC 4110 and 4283 have just arrived with Ganz-Mávag electric multiple units—yes, diesel power hauling them beyond the wires—and the carriages at left are usually used for the Capital Connection to Palmerston North. What are they doing in the Wairarapa? It was Toast Martinborough weekend, and many wine aficionados made the very good choice to catch special trains rather than drive over the Remutaka Range.

One thought on “I’ve been there, I know the way: the NZ passenger rail book is happening!

  1. As a person grown up on rail travel in the UK.
    It’s a shame that newzealand doesn’t have a passenger,
    Rail service any more.I wish there was a train from hawes bay
    To Rotorua I would use it all the time.
    As the road from Napier is terrible.
    Bring back rail travel

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: